Keith Ellison made history last month when he became the first Muslim member of Congress. Given the climate we live in today, I am certain that he fully expected to get attacked.
For example, a short while after the election, Ellison was on the Glenn Beck Show on CNN and had to deal with Beck’s ignorance as he was asked to convince Beck that he was not “working with our enemies” because, of course, if he is a Muslim he must, by default, be in league with terrorists.
Now, another right-wing hack has come out of the woodwork with more nonsense. Dennis Prager, right-wing radio host, posted a column on Townhall.com in which he expresses his ire about Ellison’s intent to take his oath of office on the Qu’ran instead of the Bible.
Prager’s column touched off a firestorm that was only fueled by more right-wing talking heads like Sean Hannity.
The problem: Prager got it all wrong!
No holy book, Bible or other, is used in the official swearing in of Congress. In a statement issued by the Anti-Defamation League, the facts are laid out and Prager is checked quite nicely, also:
Prager’s patriotic prattling is misinformed on the facts, too. No Member of Congress is officially sworn in with a Bible. Under House rules, the official swearing-in ceremony is done in the House chambers, with the Speaker of the House administering the oath of office en masse. No Bibles or other holy books are used at all. Members may, if they choose, also have a private ceremony with family and friends. At these unofficial ceremonies, Members frequently solemnize the event by taking an oath while holding a personal family Bible.
Prager ridiculously asserts that permitting Rep. Ellison to take the oath of office would “be doing more damage to the unity of America and to the value system that has formed this country than the terrorists of 9-11.” What he fails to understand is that what truly unifies all Americans is a value system built on religious freedom and pluralism, not dogmatism and coercion.
Prager presents intolerant, ugly views. His comparison of Ellison’s desire to “choose his favorite book” to that of the right of a racist elected to public office to use Hitler’s Mein Kampf is outrageous. If Prager were merely a blogger and radio talk-show host trying to be relevant and provocative, these views might not merit a response. But as a newly-appointed member of the United States Holocaust Memorial Council, Prager and his views must be held to a higher standard.
I don’t know what’s worse — Prager getting it so wrong or so many media outlets more interested in reporting the controversy than in getting the facts straight.
Popularity: 37% [?]
Sphere: Related Content
Perhaps people who think like radio host Michael Savage only exacerbate an already testy situatation.
Blair Underwood as Jesus? Samuel L. Jackson as the voice of God?
Unlike a lot of folks, I don’t have beef with Rev. Al. I don’t agree with him all the time but, unlike many, I don’t have some visceral hatred of him just because the white establishment does not hold some favorable view of him. Unlike many “black leaders”, elected or not, he speaks his mind and does not mind speaking in front of those he is criticizing.








